American Idol 2012 top 5 contestant Phillip Phillips may be an oddball, but he is apparently a loveable one to make it all the way to this point in the competition. He may be quirky and unpredictable, but his fans keep voting week after week to keep him safe.

Besides Elise Testone, who was eliminated on American Idol 2012 last week, Phillip Phillips is perhaps the contestant with the most questionable and unpredictable song choices. Sometimes he seems to have it nailed to the wall, and sometimes you have to ask what the hell he was thinking. The judges are often totally astounded when he takes an unlikely song and rocks it out and then equally confused when a song should be perfect for him and it goes all wrong.

So how was Phillip Phillips tonight with this American Idol 2012 song choices Wednesday night? Were they home runs or foul balls? Check out his second song performance video and let us know what you think in the comments section below!

Phillip Phillips — “Time of the Season” by The Zombies

>> Related:  American Idol 2012 Top 5 Recap: Who Will Go Home? (VIDEOS)

Join us here at SnarkFood.com as we bring you our American Idol 2012 top 5 live recaps on Wednesdays and Thursdays. Plus, make sure to subscribe to us on Facebook and Twitter to keep up with all the latest American Idol 2012 news.


Subscribe to Snark Food updates on Facebook, Twitter, Email, or RSS